For many men, gray hairs don’t just show up overnight. Although it’s gradual, it does change the way your hair and beard look and how you feel. While some guys embrace the “distinguished silver fox” vibe, others wanna keep a fuller, more youthful look with color.
But it’s tough to find a product that makes it quick and easy to color your hair and beard at home – without the mess, hassle, or bad results.
Just For Men has been a household name for decades, but Beard Club recently entered the ring with its Perm Color formula. We’ve been fans of Beard Club’s products for a while, so when they launched this color line, we wondered what they’d bring to the hair dye game.
We tested both brands. Here’s what we found:
Key Similarities
- Both offer solutions designed specifically for men’s beard and hair coloring
- Both aim to provide natural-looking gray coverage
- Both feature a range of shades that match your original hair
Key Differences
- One Product vs. Many: Beard Club has one versatile product that works on hair and beard┃Just For Men has separate products for hair and beard and a bunch of kits, so it can be tricky choosing the best for your scruff.
- Ease of Use: Beard Club requires no mixing, simply brush it in┃Just For Men involves mixing and extra steps, which can get messy
- Applicators: Beard Club includes a precision brush, long hair comb, and short hair comb for targeted application on both coarse and fine hair types┃Just For Men has one applicator per kit, making it harder to cover different areas with accuracy
- Touch-Ups: Beard Club can be easily reused for root touch-ups as needed┃Just For Men is often single-use, so you’ll need a new kit each time
Beard Club Overview
With Beard Club coloring your hair and beard is ridiculously easy – no mixing involved. Brush it in, wait five minutes, and boom; gray hairs vanish, and your beard’s richer, fuller, and ready to impress.
The kit comes with a precision brush, a long hair comb, and a short hair comb, so you can apply evenly and style as you go. It’s great for all hair types, coarse or fine, long or short, making it perfect for full beards or just those sneaky gray roots.
We’re also impressed by the value. The reusable 5oz tube is up to 5x larger than most competitors and costs about $4 dollars per use, totally cost-effective.
Bonus: it conditions your hair while coloring, leaving it soft and healthy.
With five natural shades (Jet Black, Real Black, Dark Brown, Medium Brown, and Light Brown) you will find your perfect match. Add a 30-day guarantee, Salon-Quality Color, and a five-minute processing time, and you’ve got a fast, fuss-free way to get back to your more dashing self.
Just For Men Overview
Just For Men has been a go-to for gray coverage for years. It’s famous for delivering reliable, natural-looking results that gradually erase the gray.
But to us, the brand feels a bit old school. Most formulas require mixing, extra steps, and a steady hand unless you want to flood your sink in hair dye. It gets the job done, but it is not exactly a grab-and-go situation.
In terms of usage, most of their dye kits are intended for one-time application. So, you have to purchase a new box each time you want a color refresh. While results are typically solid and consistent, any quick touch-ups can be inconvenient and spendy.
Final Thoughts
Both Beard Club and Just For Men cover gray adequately, but getting there is radically different.
Unlike Just For Men, which only comes with a single applicator per kit – meaning you’d need to buy multiple kits just to properly cover different areas like your beard and hair – Beard Club’s process is quick, mess-free, and affordable. Beard Club streamlines your routine with one product that does it all.
Plus, Beard Club goes beyond just color, offering all-in-one solutions like Beard Club Growth Kits and Beard Club Grooming Kits, which include grooming tools, oils, and treatments – making it a far more complete grooming brand than Just For Men. Are you ready to erase the gray and upgrade your grooming routine? Check out Beard Club’s Beard and Hair Brush-In Color today. This is the one worth trying.